S.P. Greaney is a freelance writer who's interested in social and political issues that impact society today.
In 1994, the Habitats Directive was introduced into Irish legislation. The initial aim of this directive was to encourage biodiversity within European Union member states and to ensure that natural habitats and fauna were protected.
Every six years, the government would need to submit reports to the European Union on how they were performing.
While the directive had many positive aspects to it, one factor within the directive that people opposed was the ban on turf cutting. This was introduced as certain raised and blanket bogs were nearly depleted in areas that were considered Special Areas of Conservation and National Heritage Sites.
By 1997, the government had started to implement some of the measures required by the European Union to help protect these Special Areas of Conservation and National Heritage Sites.
Progression Through the Years
By 2007, Ireland had made significant improvement in meeting standards set out in the Habitats Directive. Along with more surveys, they adopted a better approach in the method that they used to record data.
By 2013, when they released their next progress report, one area that had not seen any improvement at all was raised and blanket bogs. In this progression report it showed that Ireland were still behind in putting measures in place to start protecting these special areas of conservation and the outcome was recorded as ongoing decline.
Another report published in 2017 again confirmed that raised and blanket bogs were still continuing to decline. It also reported that there had been no further improvement made in any of these areas. This meant that the future of these bogs was in serious trouble.
- In 1997, there were 28 raised bogs considered special areas of conservation. By 2002 the number had risen to 53.
- In 2013, there were 75 bogs listed within the Natural Heritage Areas where turf cutting needed to cease.
The Bogs at Risk
Two main types of bogs are at risk.
A raised bog it is a body of land that has the consistency of spongy watery land. For thousands of years, layers and layers of decayed vegetation would build upon itself and, with the right conditions, this land gradually turns into peat which is then cut into turf.
For a blanket bog to grow, it needs waterlogged land that continues to remain wet all the time. Peat grows on wet flat terrain or sometimes on land that has a gentle slope to it.
. . . because Ireland is a member of the European Union, they are bound by the requirements of the Habitats Directive and the Birds Directive.
— Minister Josepha Madigan, Minister for Culture, Heritage and the Gaeltacht
Why Do the European Union Want Turf Cutting to Cease?
The reasons behind the European Union wanting Ireland to stop turf cutting are as follows.
- They are worried that if turf cutting doesn't cease that the peat will never get a chance to regrow and it will lead to the eradication of the bogs over time.
- The bogs are seen as a natural flood defenses.
- Cutting turf in the bogs release carbon dioxide which is a greenhouse gas which can contribute to climate change.
- Certain protected mosses and species grow and live in these bogs and if the turf cutting continues, then they will be destroyed.
Hectares Under Discussion
Cutover Peatlands (affected by domestic turf cutting)
How the Government Got Around the Ban
Initially turf cutting was to be banned immediately in 1999. But the Irish government got a derogation from the European Union which allowed them to apply the turf cutting ban in a manner that they felt would compliment their own legislation and not cause upset within the population of Ireland.
Over the next 10 years, different governments were in power and each one knew that they were under a time constraint to implement this ban on turf cutting in bogs considered special areas of conservation.
By 2011, the European Union had become frustrated with what they saw as Ireland's lack of planning to stop turf cutting in bogs. They decided to implement fines of €25,000 if the Irish Government did not ban turf cutting at designated sites within the timeframe set out.
Source: The National Raised Bog Special Areas of Conservation (SACs) Management Plan 2017—2022
Compensation for Turf Cutters
The Irish government would now need to look at ways to compensate the people who owned bogs in these areas and who relied on turf cutting for their livelihood.
In 2011 the Turf Cutting Compensation scheme was introduced and turf cutters would be paid compensation for a number of years.
There were two types of schemes people could apply under.
- The Cessation of Turf Cutting in Special Areas of Conservation.
- The Cessation of Turf Cutting in Natural Heritage Areas.
The Cessation of Turf Cutting in Special Areas of Conservation
A payment of €1500 would be paid out for 15 years as well as a one of payment of €500.
- The owner of the site must be the legal owner of the site or has the right to cut turf on this site.
- From May 25th 2010, the owner of the bog should have the legal right to remove turf from specified site.
- The legal owner should have being cutting turf on the bog for 5 years prior to May 25th 2010.
- The site must still have some form of peat resources left within the site.
- No cutting of turf on the site has occurred on it from January 1st 2010.
The Cessation of Turf Cutting in Natural Heritage Areas
A payment of €1521 would be paid for 15 years along with a one of payment of €550.
- The owner of the site must be the legal owner of said bog or has the right to cut turf on the bog.
- They must have the exclusive rights to remove turf from the site on May 25th 2010.
- They had to have cut turf in the bog for 5 years prior to January 14th, 2014.
- The bog must still have some form of peat resources left within the sit
- They have ceased cutting turf on the site from date of application for compensation.
Once these conditions were met turf cutters would be compensated as seen fit.
Future of Bogs
In 2017, a new plan was implemented to ensure that bogs would still be protected into the future and get a chance to restore themselves. A fund of €5.4 million was established to help with this restoration project.
This content reflects the personal opinions of the author. It is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and should not be substituted for impartial fact or advice in legal, political, or personal matters.
© 2011 Sp Greaney
Sp Greaney (author) from Ireland on August 28, 2014:
Thanks Mom In Gods Hands. I think us Irish people would love if it if it was not the case.
April from Fort Myers on August 28, 2014:
My husband is from Cappincur and says this is spot on. :)
Sp Greaney (author) from Ireland on May 07, 2014:
Hi maggie, that's a very good point. It seems certain sectors are more vocal in voicing their opinion than others. It's good to see that they are still fighting for what they believe in and letting nothing stand in their way.
maggie on May 07, 2014:
I notice there is no outrage in regards to environmental issues when the land is being excavated to put in a new football pitch, a shopping centre, a car park, cinema, ao another Bord Failte approved holiday home, B&B or yet another tourist connected venture but those who need to cut the turf to bring a warm comforting glow to our homes and the homes of our children are indeed a new band of criminals that will become the threat the idea of a totally dependant "New Society" Completely incomprehensible.
Sp Greaney (author) from Ireland on June 16, 2013:
@ rj, thanks for your comment. You're obviously well informed in your facts about this topic and I agree with what you say. Obviously the men in the 'offices' just want to do what they can to keep the EU people happy. At least people are standing their ground and taking action against the higher up people.
rj on June 15, 2013:
there is 1.25 million of bog that has not ever been cut in Ireland
then how come the NP&WS tell us that only 1% of our bog is in good
shape with a 500 million euro budget thay should know it not the turf cutting that doing the harm as the none cut area are in a worse condition
than were turf is being cut.
before the famine there was 8 million people using turf for to heat there home and help grow there crops.
now a days theres only a small percent of people do so
the EU directive ask for 5% of bogland persavation not the 50% being
implymented by all the public officie,s in Ireland this is jobs for the boys using taxpayer money. sending more people out of the country or on to the dole.
the small amount of bog lost could be planted with renewable crops that
are good for wild life and the planet BUT that would just be sensable Ireland won,t do sensable.
this country needs
Sp Greaney (author) from Ireland on January 19, 2012:
@ Perty, I think a 1/5 of our population is in your country :-). They are leaving here as quick as the planes are flying out.
Perty on January 18, 2012:
Interesting! I have often wondered what turf was like, as it has been mentioned in many books I have read.
A lot of the Irish people must be in Australia at the moment as I run into them all over Sydney.
Great writing by the way.
Sp Greaney (author) from Ireland on November 15, 2011:
@ shadowprancer, thanks for your comment. Lets just say Ireland is having a few problems at the moment. We are all hoping it will get better in a few year.
shadowprancer from Washington on November 12, 2011:
Very interesting topic. Thank you for informing me. I had heard about the problems with depleting the bogs, but I didn't know the full extent of the issue.
Sp Greaney (author) from Ireland on July 05, 2011:
@ Sushant Thankur, thanks for your comment.
Sushant Thakur on July 05, 2011:
Just read your hub on traffup. It's an interesting and informative hub. Voting it up
Sp Greaney (author) from Ireland on July 02, 2011:
@ Karen Wodke, in the countryside piped natural gas is not available. It's either oil, coal or turf.
People who have central heating still love to have an open fire and burn turf. It feels more homey.
Karen Wodke from Midwest on July 02, 2011:
This is fascinating! I just take my central heat and air for granted, I guess. Do they not use natural gas to heat their homes? I am intrigued.