Skip to main content

Would Mitt Romney Have Been a Bad President of the United States? Of Course Not

Ara is a journalism graduate from California State University, Northridge, who is always looking to explore his writing opportunities.

One Reason Some Say Romney Would Have Been a Bad President

After the 2012 Presidential election, I was wondering and asking the question: would Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan have been bad for the United States? While the Obama administration was asking Mitt Romney to release ten years of his tax returns, and Paul Ryan was criticizing Obama because of the economy, there is something that is really important.

And that event is that if Mitt Romney were to win the presidency, it was estimated that the US would have lost up to one million more jobs in 2013 alone. That is a lot of lost jobs. But the fundamental question of this article is would Mitt Romney have been a bad President of the United States had he defeated Barack Obama in the 2012 Presidential Election? I try to make the case that he would not have been a bad President.

Mitt Romney, Republican Presidential Nominee and former Governor of Massachusetts.

Mitt Romney, Republican Presidential Nominee and former Governor of Massachusetts.

Some Reasons Why the US Lost So Many Jobs

We have already lost too many jobs in this country because of employers’ refusal to hire workers. They refuse to hire anybody because in their mind it is cheaper to hire no one. To add to this mess, many employers say that they are reluctant to hire new employees because of the Obama care health insurance plan. What are they afraid of? Many companies are sitting on huge piles of cash and they can hire more employees but they just don’t want to. It is because of corporate greed pure and simple. They want to keep as much of the money to themselves as they can. The amount of lost jobs, especially in the manufacturing sector, has other reasons behind it which is beyond the scope of this written piece.

Let’s put things in perspective here for a moment. During the Bill Clinton Presidency (1993-2001), there was a trade agreement that was signed between the US, Canada, and Mexico. Those that were in favor of the agreement argued that NAFTA would lead to the creation of jobs for the US economy. While the agreement helped to make trade investment for businesses easier without them having to deal with the movement of labor across borders, by 2011, it was estimated that there were 682,900 jobs lost due to NAFTA. All of this happened under a Democratic administration.

Before I go any further on this, let me say that I was one of those people that did not trust Romney and even signed a petition urging him to properly release his tax returns. I ended up voting for Romney during the 2012 election, feeling that Obama had not done enough to improve the overall economic and business standing of the United States. To be fair, Obama has been under scrutiny for many things which is a different topic for a different day.

Mitt Romney As a President of the United States

The Liberal Point of View About Romney

Here is what liberals have said about Romney:

  • The election of Romney and Ryan would cause the rich to get richer according to arguments from people on the left.
  • Romney would have increased taxes on the middle class and this would destroy an already fragile economy and kill any job creation in this country.
Mitt Romney in 2015.

Mitt Romney in 2015.

Even John McCain Would Have Had a Hard Time With the Economy in 2008

Would the election of John McCain in 2008 instead of Barack Obama have really changed things? I personally doubt it because this country is still struggling economically even in 2016. No one could have fixed the country in just 4 years. It may take up to another ten years to really see improvement. Patience is a virtue for a good reason and many do not have patience. It takes time to fix a broken country. But time is running out for Obama who has only until January 2017 to finish whatever goals he set out to accomplish.

Scroll to Continue

Read More From Soapboxie

But to get back to the focus of this article, would the election of Romney and Ryan have been bad for America? At the time before the 2012 Presidential Election, I certainly thought so. Romney’s defeat in the election was because of many factors but one factor that was huge was Romney’s inability to win over the Hispanic vote. This was due to his far right stance on immigration. Romney himself was said to have been shell shocked. These elections are decided by which candidate wins the key states. After Ohio went for Obama in 2012, Romney’s chances of winning were over but it was also said that no one was able to process this result. Defeat is sometimes very hard to take and it was especially tough for Romney and Ryan. The victories for Obama in Colorado and eventually Florida were more than a sucker punch to the Romney campaign. Those victories assured Obama of another solid win which resulted in his second term in office.

How Do We Get the American Economy Moving Again? Two People Offer Different Views on the Greatness of Romney

We have come to the point that we need to come together as a country and realize the future health of this country economically is going to depend on how well both major parties are able to work together to solve the major issues of our time. Steve Forbes has argued that Romney would have made a better president than what was seen during his campaign. It was back in 2010 during an interview with Neil Cavuto of Fox News that Romney asserted that the Obama Administration spent $787 billion as part of a stimulus plan to create new jobs and there was not a single net new job created.

Politics is also about what candidates say to better their standing so they can win votes. Michael Snyder of the End of the American Dream website gives 16 reasons why he feels that Mitt Romney would have been a terrible president for the United States. While I am no politician and I don’t have all the answers I do know that effective change in Washington will only come about through both Democrats and Republicans willing to compromise to solve this nation’s difficulties. So what is the solution to making sure that this country gets back on the right track economically? Well, one thing we can do is to reduce the salaries of these professional athletes and invest more money into programs for education, infrastructure, and the economy.

The Video in Which Romney Criticizes the Obama Economic Stimulus Plan

Final Thoughts on Whether Mitt Romney Would Have Been Bad as a US President

Would Mitt Romney have been a bad president? It is tough to say because we currently do not have enough effective bipartisanship in our Congress and as long as this continues, the party in charge of things in the White House is going to have a very tough time getting legislation passed. As one of the largest representative democracies in the world, the United States deserves to have leaders that will make sure that there is a strong middle class where people can work hard, send their children to college, and have enough money for their retirement years. Romney certainly would have been different for the United States but a bad president? It is too tough to say.

Regardless of whether we had Romney in the Oval Office or not, this country still has to be able to create a solid middle class so that those people that want jobs can get them. However, there is one major hurdle to creating a strong middle class and that is the outsourcing of jobs that has been happening. For instance, the US manufacturing sector decreased from 19.5 million back in June 1979 to 11.5 million in December of 2009. That’s a total of 8 million manufacturing jobs lost over 30 years! These middle class jobs have been the biggest strength of the US economy for decades and these losses have done much damage to this country’s economic health. In spite of Obama saying that he would bring hope and change, the election of Romney may or may not have been a bad choice. Only time will tell. As time has passed, I have begun to have respect for Willard "Mitt" Romney. He can speak very well, is intelligent, and knows how frustrated and angry many Americans have become as a result of the decline of the American manufacturing sector and the loss of millions of good paying jobs. Romney would not have been any worse than George W. Bush.

If the people of the United States really wanted to have change, they had their chance in 2012 to vote for it. Instead, the United States chose a man in 2016 who will more than likely be considered the worst president in history. If Mitt Romney had won the 2012 Presidential Election, there would be no way that the country would have been stuck with Donald Trump. I will agree with former President Obama that Romney and McCain are two very decent men.

Mitt Romney Would Have United the GOP

This writer says that Mitt Romney would not have been a bad President. Though I am not a big fan of the GOP, there are still some decent Republicans that would be good Presidents. After all, let’s be fair. One of the greatest men in American history, Abraham Lincoln was a Republican and a caring person. Dwight Eisenhower who served in the US Army during World War II also was a decent President. I remember Barack Obama mentioning during the 2016 Election campaign that if either John McCain or Mitt Romney had been President, he would not have been as concerned as he is now. Karen Hughes who served as a counselor to President George W. Bush makes a great point about Romney when she says “he’s lived a life of faithful commitment to his family and his church,” (Hughes, 2012). If you want to be a great leader, one of the most important qualities to have is strong family values and a commitment to church. Our current President Donald Trump is now on his third marriage and he does not have a good relationship with daughter Tiffany whose mother is Marla Maples. Romney is not perfect, but the GOP would have been more unified and stronger with him.


Hughes, K. (2012, April 22). Politico . Retrieved from

Mitt Romney Makes Good Points Here

This content reflects the personal opinions of the author. It is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and should not be substituted for impartial fact or advice in legal, political, or personal matters.

© 2016 Ara Vahanian

Related Articles