Suffer the Youth of Pennhurst State Hospital
Aerial View of the Hospital , 1934
And the "Feeble-Minded" Were Shut Away
Originally called Eastern Pennsylvania State Institution for the Feeble-Minded and Epileptic, Pennhurst State School and Hospital, was built in the early 1900s. The first buildings went up from 1903 to 1908. A person labeled "Patient Number 1" was admitted November 23, 1908, when the institution opened. This was the first indication that patients would be losing their identity and respect.
Children who were not perfect and considered "feeble-minded" were shut away from society, their families, and everything they knew. There was one little boy, Johnny, who was there in 1968 because he was considered "delinquent and uneducated".
Children were admitted to this institute if they were strabismus (A visual defect in which one eye cannot focus with the other on an object because of imbalance of the eye muscles), had other defective sight or hearing problems, were mute (or even semi-mute), had imperfect speech, were paralytic, epileptic, blind, had an imperfect gait, imperfect comprehension, deformity of face, head, limbs and/or feet, micro cephalic (abnormally small head), or hydro cephalic (congenital condition in which an abnormal accumulation of fluid in the cerebral ventricles causes enlargement of the skull and compression of the brain, destroying much of the neural tissue). Even children who had "offensive habits" were admitted.
Every Child has a Right to Explore Meadows and Blow Dandelion Seeds
Sufficient Reasons ?
I find it so hard to believe that these conditions were considered sufficient reasons to shut children away from society. The Commissions for the Care of the Feeble-Minded, which was appointed by the legislature in 1913, stated that the disabled were unfit for citizenship and posed a menace to the peace, and thus recommended a program of custodial care. In the Biennial Report to the Legislature submitted by the Board of Trustees, Pennhurst's Chief Physician quoted Henry H. Goddard, a leading eugenicist in his report:
Every feeble-minded person is a potential criminal. The general public, although more convinced today than ever before that it is a good thing to segregate the idiot or the distinct imbecile, they have not as yet been convinced as to the proper treatment of the defective delinquent, which is the brighter and more dangerous individual.— Henry H. Goddard
"Every feeble-minded person is a potential criminal." This is heartbreaking to read and to know that this belief was ever accepted as truth is like a sledgehammer hitting the Liberty Bell.
Pennhurst State Hospital Admin Building
In 1968 a shocking and ground-breaking report by NBC10 exposed the sad conditions and shameful care of patients at Pennhurst. Twenty-eight-hundred children were still in the institute, some had grown up there and were now adults -- abandoned as children, they still had no one to love them or help them. Hyperactive children and delinquent children were admitted and treated as insane, or idiots.
WARNING: The following video is heart-breaking, shocking, alarming, and not at all pleasant to view -- but, I watched every second of it to become more aware of what Bill Baldini wanted to express to the public and show conditions the mentally ill had to live with. Even today there are people who once lived at Pennhurst and deserve to have their dignity, respect and love restored to them. There are people who died there who deserve to have dignity and respect restored to their memory.
Bill Baldini Investigation
Bill Baldini, who was the journalist who went to Pennhurst and investigated, interviewed doctors and patients and exposed the conditions, could not finish the final segment. He collapsed under sheer exhaustion and was unable to complete his final report. Bill Baldini deserves respect and appreciation for his dedication and courage for what he accomplished.
Badini's 1968 documentary led to cases presented in the Supreme Court about conditions at Pennhurst State School and Hospital and allowed the nation to see the way the residents at Pennhurst lived -- these people had broken spirits, they were unloved, uncared for, and their constitutional rights were denied them.
A class-action case against Pennhurst State School and Hospital was ruled by U.S. District Judge Raymond J. Broderick in 1977, where the institution was found guilty of violating patient's constitutional rights. Pennhurst State School was forced to close by 1987 following several allegations of abuse, beginning a De-institutionalization process that would last several years.
Its 460 patients were discharged or transferred to other facilities. Pennhurst was responsible for discussing treatment plans with each patient's family to decide what would be the best for each patient.
Halderman v. Pennhurst State School and Hospital
The allegations of abuse led to the first lawsuit of its kind in the United States called, Pennhurst State School and Hospital vs. Halderman, which asserted that the mentally retarded have a constitutional right to living quarters and education.
Terry Lee Halderman had been a resident of Pennhurst, and upon release she filed suit in the district court on behalf of herself and other residents of Pennhurst. The complaint alleged that conditions at Pennhurst were unsanitary, inhumane and dangerous, violating the fourteenth amendment, and that Pennhurst used cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the eighth and fourteenth amendments, as well as the Pennsylvania Mental Health and Retardation Act of 1966 (MH/MR).
While the District Court agreed that certain of the patient's rights had been violated, upon appeal, the case was eventually overturned at the U.S. Supreme Court which found that the federal courts cannot order state officials to comply with state laws, due to the Eleventh Amendment
Pennhurst was closed in 1987.
What was meant to be a place of beauty and help for the mentally challenged is now a haunting place of sorrow and bad memories.
Grave Concerns Association
Laurel Lemke of Grave Concerns Association in Lakewood, Washington, is a valued friend of mine. It is Laurel who led me to the history of Pennhurst State School and Hospital. It is because of Laurel and the people who work with her -- it is because of the people who have suffered in the past due to the stigma of society regarding the mentally ill -- it is because of the people today who still suffer from mental illness and do not get proper care, love and help, that I have dedicated my time and effort to write this article and others to follow. Laurel, you and your co-workers are truly Angels on Earth.
- Grave Concerns Association
© 2010 Phyllis Doyle Burns