Skip to main content

Reasons Faithful Members Leave the Church

Margaret Minnicks has been an online writer for many years. She researches and shares remedies for using certain products for illnesses.

Why do people leave a church?

Why do people leave a church?

Why Do Faithful Members Leave the Church?

Pastors and top leaders can't help but notice that people who have been faithful for many years often leave the church. Some pastors tend to overlook the trend and say they are called to preach only to the people left in the church. They should seek to find out the reason people who were once faithful are finding it necessary to leave. If they knew the reason, it might help to prevent others from leaving.

They should seek to find out the reason people who were once faithful are leaving. If pastors knew the reasons, perhaps the reasons could be addressed to prevent others from leaving.

Not a Spur-of-the-Moment Decision

If the truth is to be told, most people do not leave the church on the spur of the moment. People have reported that they have endured many months and even years of being dissatisfied before they made the ultimate decision to leave.

It is usually the little things adding up that convince churchgoers it would be in their best interest to leave.

It's a Hard Choice for Faithful Members

It is never easy for members to leave a church, and it would be wise for pastors to find out the reasons. If a faithful member leaves, it must be a good reason to do so because a faithful member would never leave a church a church he has been invested in for years.

Usually, when a faithful member leaves, it is the lesser of many evils as the saying goes. The member more than likely is between a rock and a hard place. He is miserable and doesn't foresee any changes in the future.

The situation becomes like the biblical story found in 2 Kings 7:3-4 about four lepers who decided they were going to die if they stayed where they were. However, if they got up and left, at least they had a chance of survival. Spoiler alert: They left and they did survive!

Two Groups of People Who Leave the Chuch

It is important to know that there are many people who become church dropouts. People in that category are those who go to church out of habit because their parents forced them to go when they were younger. Therefore, they keep up that habit out of obligation. They attend church, but they never become committed. They don't connect with people in the church or get involved with any ministry.

It is much easier for those people to leave because they haven't really been invested in the church, and the church really hasn't invested in them.

However, there is another group of people who leave the church. That group includes faithful members who have had active roles in the church and have done considerable work within the church. They have invested in the church, and at one time the church invested in them.

When the church ceases to live up to its mission of providing care for all, these people become discouraged. Even though some of those people were faithful members in leadership positions, they saw no other way except to leave the church.

Signs a Member Is Considering Leaving

Here are some signs that indicate a member is not satisfied and considering leaving the church. Pastors and other top officials should pay attention and do something about it.

  • Irregular attendance. The first sign that a member is not satisfied at church is when he or she stops attending worship service and other church events on a regular basis.
  • Giving has stopped. A big sign is when a member stops giving, especially if he had no problem giving before. The faithful member will reduce his usual tithes and then stop giving altogether.
  • Not involved in ministries. If a person has no interest in ministries, small groups, Bible study, or Sunday school, it might mean that the person is no longer interested in what goes on in the church.
  • Not fellowshipping with other members. When a person is not satisfied with the church, he might not want to communicate or fellowship with other members.

Gradual or Abrupt Departure

Most of the time, faithful members do not leave the church suddenly without giving it much consideration. Sometimes members take a long time before they leave because they want to make the best decision according to God's plan for their lives. Their leaving is gradual because they want to make sure they are doing the right thing.

Same Reasons in Different Churches

It is safe to say that the reasons faithful members leave one church are usually the same reasons others are leaving their churches. In other words, while the people and churches are different, the reasons remain the same.

Through consultations, interviews, and surveys, the following are main reasons people leave churches they have been members of for many years. This article will list some of the top reasons; however, there are certainly more.

Conflict in the Church

People have conflicts within their family and on their job. They shouldn't have to deal with conflict within the church. No church is perfect, but there should be a certain degree of harmony in the church. The church should take inventory and find out why there is discord in a place that should be a refuge for all people.

Members Not Given Needed Support

Sometimes people don't get the support they need from the church when they go through a personal tragedy or traumatic event. When those people don't get the support they need from the church, they decide to discontinue their support to the church.

Church Burnout

Sometimes faithful members feel burnout because of the church's demands on them. Much work is given to faithful members because they can be counted on to do it efficiently and in a timeless manner. Those who are loaded down with programs, needless meetings, unnecessary training and other responsibilities eventually get to a point that they are so burned out that they don't enjoy going to church any longer.

The Bible should be the church's instruction book.

The Bible should be the church's instruction book.

Not Being Fed

Too often people say they left a church because they were not being fed. In other words, they believe they were not getting the teaching or preaching they needed to strengthen them spiritually. Sometimes they are right. However, it should be a shared responsibility between the church and the people.

Churchgoers should not rely totally on a two-hour worship service on Sunday mornings to give them everything they need in order to develop spiritually. They should participate in their own blessings by reading the Bible and studying it on their own.

They should attend Bible study and Sunday school where they can ask questions about what they don't understand. However, pastors and teachers fail the people if they don't provide spirit-filled preaching and teaching.

Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth. (2 Timothy 2:15)

Using Sermons From the Internet

Pastors fail the people when they download just any sermon off the internet and preach it regardless of the issues and concerns in his own church. It is acceptable to get inspiration from sermons that other preachers have preached, but the most effective sermon comes from a pastor who has received it from God for his own congregation at a particular time.

A sermon preached in North Carolina last month might not be the sermon that a congregation needs in Delaware this coming Sunday.

Good advice for preachers is never try to stand tall in the pulpit on Sunday morning without first having knelt before God days in advance.

Every church should use the Bible as its book of instructions.

Every church should use the Bible as its book of instructions.

Other Reasons Faithful Members Leave The Church

Way People FeelReason People Feel The Way The Do

Not Validated

People are left out and forgotten on the job or in the community. Church should be different.

Spiritual Abuse

The church fails its people when it overlooks the spiritual needs of the people.

Unfair Treatment

God is no respecter of people, but everybody in the church is not treated the same.


The whole church is in trouble when one or a few people make all the decisions without considering opinions from others.


Everybody who belongs to a church also belongs to the family of God. There should be no favorites in the church.


The church fails when family members are considered more important than other members of the church.

No Confidentiality

What's shared in the pastor's study shouldn't be aired from the pulpit the next Sunday.

Unfulfilled Expectation

When the needs of a person are not met, he believes the church isn't doing its job. People go to church to be helped; not to be hurt.


Pastors and top leaders fail miserably when they don't give members freedom to use their gifts without interferring.

Advice for People Who Leave a Church

There is nothing wrong if a person leaves a church when directed by God. No one is advocating church-hopping, but when people are absolutely sure God is leading them away from a certain church, then that person will be disobedient if he or she doesn't leave. However, that person should connect with another church as soon as possible.

This content reflects the personal opinions of the author. It is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and should not be substituted for impartial fact or advice in legal, political, or personal matters.