ActivismEconomyGovernmentMilitarySocial IssuesUS PoliticsWorld Politics

Facebook Live: Friend or Foe?

Updated on May 14, 2017
Camille Harris profile image

As one of Facebook's original users, Camille has seen its evolution. She currently abstains from it, but keeps abreast of its developments.

By the time you read this, there's a good chance someone else's death was broadcast live on Facebook. Of these deaths, Mark Zuckerberg - the 21st century's most famous Wunderkind - will probably say that Facebook is doing everything it can to prevent these kinds of tragedies in the future. He said just that at Facebook's April conference:

"We have a lot of work and we will keep doing all we can to prevent tragedies like this from happening,"

The point of Facebook Live, according to Zuckerberg - and, by extension, Facebook - is a "raw, emotional, visceral way to share and connect..." Watching people suffering breakdowns and murdering people LIVE is certainly emotional and visceral, but is it good for society? Is Facebook Live a friend or a foe?


Pros

  • Free to use
  • Easy to use
  • Helps people connect

Source
  • Free to use: Facebook is - and has always been - free to use. The platform began experimenting with ads in the form of "sponsored stories" in early 2012. Users currently see ads embedded in their "feeds". Advertising comprises most of the company's revenue. The ad-supported model works, and the company appears to have no plans to charge.
  • Easy to use: Starting a live feed takes three simple steps. Presumably, anyone who can post on Facebook can start a live video from either their computer or phone.
  • Helps people connect: At nearly 1.86 billion users (aka 1/4 of Earth's population), Facebook is the largest social network in the world. If you want to connect with the greatest number of people possible, Facebook is probably the cheapest and most effective way to do it.

Source

Cons

  • No preventative measures in place
  • Violent content may encourage copycats
  • Violent content negatively impacts children

Source

Recent* Facebook Live Deaths

(*Not a comprehensive list)

  • May 13, 2017:
    A 33 year old musician set himself on fire in front of his ex-girlfriend's bar. He "broadcast the moment he set himself alight".
  • April 26, 2017: An Alabama man live streamed his suicide.
  • April 25, 2017: An 11 month old baby was killed by her 20 year old father in Thailand. He then killed himself.
  • April 16, 2017: A 74 year old man was killed by a stranger who live streamed it.
  • January 25, 2017: A 14 year old girl from Miami live streamed her suicide.
  • January 23, 2017: An aspiring actor died after shooting himself.
  • October 11, 2016: A young Turkish man committed suicide after expressing his devastation over a breakup.

Source

Was the writing on the wall with Justin.tv?

In a now prescient article, gigaom.com author Liz Gannes reported on the death of 19 year old Abraham Biggs. Abraham, aka CandyJunkie, committed suicide by ingesting pills. He did so live on Justin.tv. Gannes asks "...what could sites like Justin.tv possibly do to prevent live-streamed snuff films?"

Despite nearly a decade of innovation (and hopefully research), preventative measures are few and far between. Live stream technology - and social media in general - has the power to connect us. It also has the power to harm us, starting with the most vulnerable and impressionable of our society: our children.

Is Facebook Live a friend or foe?

See results

Comments

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • Camille Harris profile image
      Author

      Camille H 10 days ago from SF Bay Area

      Great insights, Joween. Thank you so much for sharing your experience.

    • joween18 profile image

      Joween Flores 10 days ago

      Facebook is basically a good platform with its features, but some people tend to abuse it. It is the primary "wall" in someone's life by posting your emotions to it. It can summarized as a digital library of emotions of real people. However, because of its free-to-use nature, it is also bombarded by people who can physically and mentally abuse other people.

      Facebook is a tap or click away to show people your emotions. I admit, I had once thought of suicide and planned to post something before doing it and obviously, I realized my mistake and didn't do it.

      In relation to this article, Facebook Live is just a tool. It can't be a friend or a foe, the people behind every stream should take responsibility of their actions. Also, people who are close to the person streaming should always monitor their activities.

    • Camille Harris profile image
      Author

      Camille H 2 weeks ago from SF Bay Area

      Thanks for your comment, Sanjay!

    • Camille Harris profile image
      Author

      Camille H 2 weeks ago from SF Bay Area

      Thanks for your comment, @MizBejabbers! I agree ("people will always misuse something, no matter how beneficial it is to others"). I have no idea what the solution to an issue like this is, but I figure more education and conversations about it can't hurt. Thank you for contributing to that conversation.

    • SANJAY LAKHANPAL profile image

      Sanjay Sharma 2 weeks ago from Mandi (HP) India

      In the present age of identity crisis, a large chunk of population wants to become popular and powerful even in negative manner. The live streaming of negative things like suicides, murders, rapes etc. should be immediately removed by Facebook.

    • MizBejabbers profile image

      MizBejabbers 2 weeks ago

      Too much of any good thing can become dangerous or even deadly. People need water, but a person can drink himself to death. Ever hear of water poisoning? My point is that people will always misuse something, no matter how beneficial it is to others, and it is not fair to deprive the moderates because of a few fanatics. My family uses Facebook to keep in touch, and that includes family members that have never met. We are able to get acquainted and carry on conversations just as if we lived in the same town. I have a cousin whose “other side” of the family are Europeans, and I’ve been privileged to get acquainted with them. I’m sure there are others who can tell a similar story. However, despite the positive side, an 11-year-old girl did have her own page and did harm to my family. Her family removed her page.

      I do get tired of political soapboxes, but I like the way Facebook is used to bring about awareness of social issues like abused animals or people in need. I think for every tragedy posted on Facebook, there are probably millions of positive posts. I think that any large organization that answers complaints by removing tragic or distasteful posts is doing its job. So I don’t believe in throwing out the baby with the bathwater.

    Click to Rate This Article