Top Arguments for the Death Penalty - Soapboxie - Politics
Updated date:

Top Arguments for the Death Penalty

Author:

Arguments For the Death Penalty; Death Penalty Pros

1. The Death Penalty Can Properly Deliver Justice to Those Who Have Killed Others

Capital punishment is necessary to deliver justice -- especially to victims of murder and extreme violence. The death penalty provides for retribution against perpetrators and makes sure that they pay for their actions. Without the death penalty, it's otherwise difficult to make murderers pay sufficiently for their crime, as no punishment other than death really equates to that of the crime of killing.

A society that doesn't deliver justice is a society which will collapse. Criminals need to be held accountable for their actions. While no one enjoys the thought of having to kill someone, it can also be argued that the murderer bought the punishment on him or herself when he or she took the life of another.

2. The Death Penalty is Necessary to Deter Other Criminals

One of the best arguments for the death penalty is that capital punishment is a huge deterrent we have to prevent others from committing heinous crimes. The best way to deal with crime obviously is to stop it from happening in the first place. In turn, the best way to do that is to deter criminals from committing crimes.

When it comes to murder, torture and other heinous crimes, the best deterrent we have is the death penalty. Criminals should be aware that that if they commit a serious crime, then their punishment will be equally as serious. No one wants to die -- this is why using the death penalty as a deterrent is an effective way of stopping crimes from happening in the first place. It's also in the criminal's best interests. How so? Because, ultimately, not turning into a criminal in the first place should be in anyone's best interests. It can be seen as a disservice to those in the criminal justice system if our punishments aren't severe enough when we haven't effectively deterred criminals from entering the system.

arguments-for-and-aginst-the-death

3. The Death Penalty is Necessary to Protect Society

Some criminals simply cannot be allowed to keep living because every moment they're alive is another minute that they're a threat to the community. These criminals must be killed because keeping them alive puts their fellow prisoners, their guards, and the wider community at risk. Some criminals are simply so far gone that they're beyond help and will always be a major risk to society. For these criminals who essentially have no hope for redemption anymore, the only remaining option is to remove them from existence.

Violent criminals pose risks that are just too great for them to be allowed to live. Many run the risk of being at risk by these criminals, including but not limited to:

  • Fellow prisoners are the people who are most at risk. One of the reasons prisons are so dangerous is because they are full of murderers and rapists -- it would be unjust to the other inmates to expose them to such violent offenders.
  • Guards are at risk, as well. Prison officers are often assaulted and even killed by offenders who should have received the death penalty.
  • The wider community is also at risk from violent offenders who either escape prison or are paroled early due to an ineffective parole system.

The safest solution, therefore, is to kill violent offenders before they can be a threat once again.

4. The Death Penalty is Necessary for Families of Victims to Move On Properly

The death penalty is necessary because many victims' families will never be able to feel safe or live a normal life again if they know that the person who killed their family members is still alive. Even if the criminal is placed in the most secure facility possible, fear still grips the families of the victims. While this fear may be irrational, that doesn't make it any less real.

We must consider the rights of these families to live normal lives when sentencing murderers; we should prioritize their rights over those of the violent criminal. We also mustn't let a violent offender continue to harm others from the inside, even if they're not intentionally doing so. This applies especially to criminals who have made threats against other people in society and family members of other victims.

arguments-for-and-aginst-the-death

5. The Death Penalty is Cheaper Than a Lifetime Prison Term

One of the more controversial arguments for the death penalty is that the cost of keeping someone incarcerated for the duration of their natural life is huge. This is a cost that society shouldn't have to pay. Violent criminals and murderers shouldn't be taking away tax dollars from things like education and health care. The argument here is that we simply can't afford to keep these people alive nor do we have any responsibility to do so. It can be said that they brought their punishment on themselves when they committed their crime and they're the ones who should have to pay for their crimes, not us.

Comments

thatthicckid on January 28, 2020:

honestly if they are trying to be thicker than me then we have an issue...

MG Singh emge from Singapore on January 27, 2020:

Nice article. I am all in favor of the death penalty for heinous crimes.

The All Knowing on January 27, 2020:

You don't want the person to die you want them to suffer.

Nemo on December 27, 2019:

So long as the possibility that an innocent person could be murdered by the state, then the entire system of capital punishment is deeply immoral and unjust.

mom on June 18, 2019:

I want free vbuckz

Delaney.C on March 15, 2019:

For all of you saying that the Death Penalty costs more than life in prison, you are right, but over time the more people that get put in prison without the possibility of parole, that low cost will become greater as time passes and as more and more criminals are convicted. While the cost of the Death Penalty will remain the same.

sphen on February 04, 2019:

yea lol

Mr. Hughes on November 28, 2018:

Ok for everyone saying the death penalty is wrong, think about it. you cannot sit there and tell me as others have said if your child got rapped or something similar to that, that you wouldnt want to see justice for that, along with the fact that we shouldnt have a debate over this anyway! why? because in reality people should be doing the right thing. What makes people think it is ok to just go and take someone elses life for no reason at all. A suffiecent reason that is.And for everyone sticking up for "No death penalty" your sticking up for the right for people to just kill people and be allowed to live in prison.

SueZann on October 24, 2018:

"Why Kill People, Who Kill People, to show us Humans that Killing People is Wrong"....

I was stabbed left for dead and watched my father Rev. Bill Bosler stabbed to death...Dec. 22, 1986. I was finally able to forgive the man who did it and worked 10 1/2 years to get him off of death row and in for the rest of his life.

When I finally forgave him, I no longer needed him to say "thank you for saving my life" o r"thanks for giving my another chance" or even "thanks for forgiving me"

1) If I were to agree with the Gov't and help them execute/kill him (the murdererer) I would be an accessory to his murder. I refuse to be like that man.

"

2) If I were to help the Gov't kill him, I would dishonor my father and his name. (My father was also against the death penalty)

3) It would not bring my father back

4) There would be zero closure

5) My healing process would never be able to happen

6) If I didn't forgive him, it would be killing myself slowly, internally..

forgiveness is not for the other person...forgiveness is for me...

it took me 5 1/2 years to 100% fully forgive him...the moment I forgave him, I was Free from the pain, I gave myself for not forgiving..

7) Fact: Cost more to Execute, than in for life

8) Arbitrary or Capricious: Furman v. Georgia

9) There have been innocent men and women, exonerated from death row before they were executed ( it could be you or a family member)

10) There were also people executed and later found innocent....

Deathpenaltyinfo.org.... has FACTS on the death penalty, I strongly suggest you read/study both sides of ever issue before you debate.

People say, "eye for and eye"...if it was an 'eye for an eye' we all know, the world would be blind

How can us humans, take God's decision over to decide on when we die...

I could go on....but I will leave you all with this.....

"If human rights are not for everyone, then there are no human rights at all" -Volker Beck-

Let there be Peace on Earth and Let it Begin with ALL of us.....

Beth on October 08, 2018:

My dad says that they should bring it back. Yes its wrong to commit crimes but prisoners sjould be given an extra chance to CHANGE. We ALL make mistakes. Im only 13 and here i am debating.

Anonomys on September 18, 2018:

LoL LoL

Nicole Leatherman on July 15, 2018:

I get everyone's view and have much respect to all. I personally don't believe we should keep a murderer alive, if it's black and white irrefutable that person is guilty, forget the electric chair, or shots a .33 cent bullet would be just fine. If your son or daughter was gang raped & murdered, would you want to see your tax dollars going towards keeping this scum alive? In Japan, it works as a Major Deterrent. https://www.nippon.com/en/features/h00101/ If you're going to rape a woman & the penalty is castration would that deter you? There is always vigilante justice These people are heroes https://listverse.com/2014/10/20/10-people-who-got... Be honest if it were your son wouldn't you do the same thing? I know I would. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oi3Hyxuf5AE

fuck off on June 29, 2018:

every single last one of your dumbass Arguments is just plain wrong… an execution Costs more than Lifetime in Prison, death Penalty does not affect the crime rates and if someone is truly sad about their loss they will not want more blood to be spilled, the rest is debatable, subjective but everyone with a Little humanity in them would be against it.

dr checkan nuget on June 28, 2018:

have you seen the new bargain bucket boiiiiis its so cool that's what I wann a have as my last meal

cameron on March 18, 2018:

i agree with all of you people

the great debater on February 20, 2018:

all your points can be nallified as they hold no water .. it is cheaper to keep a person in jail as it costs 500 000 compared to the 2 million for the death penalty .thats the first thing ..secondly murder is unjustiffiable..how can you control death rate when you kill the killer ..exactly what message are yu sending.....death penalty sends a message of that human life is variable ..death penalty goes against all the laws ..the right to life ..right to human dignity ...right to equality and the right to be free from cruel inhuman punishments ...furthermore, death penalty manifests philosophy of indefensible dispair i.e no reform, no repentance, no inherent spectre of hope or spirituality .... with this i rest my case .... basically, killing does no justice as society cannot succumb to the eye for an eye doctrine,and the state rather the world must not stoop to the killers level...... i am only 16 but i know whats right for a parent and knowing that your child was murdered is not the best way to go ... thank you ...

Sarah on January 26, 2018:

I totally don't agree with the death penalty

A guy on December 18, 2017:

Define "living life to the fullest". Do these guys really have a life to live? To me the life their living is a life of crime, some people never change...

batman on November 16, 2017:

I agree with the death penalty because criminals are getting off too easy these days. They deserve to die of any type of punishment that includes breaking the law.

Naruto on November 14, 2017:

I agree with the death penalty because the person gets to face his own action with is murder

medt on August 29, 2017:

Its matter of life and justice so its not apropriate to argue about cost. what I see is crime should be punished. You are not killing the henious offender, you punish them with death. Someone can't simply get away with killing and rape just with forgivness and 'salvations'.

Lol on July 10, 2017:

You guys are crazy! We all have life easier and we should save them no matter what!

jlyn on March 13, 2017:

i agree of death penalty for stop a murder

drake on March 01, 2017:

i am for it it gets rid of theses bad people as long as they can prove it

hippydude on February 27, 2017:

i'm in favor of death penalty and this just opened my eyes even more!

riinya enid on February 16, 2017:

kill them, true we cannot afford to keep them alive

jeff on February 06, 2017:

can i ahve the name of the person that made this post for research purposes

Erik on January 31, 2017:

The so called arguments for death penalty was pretty bad and almost all could you just be counterd. For example 2 its technically proventhat its not less killing then in the countries with out death penalty.

Joe on January 09, 2017:

I see the death penalty aka capital punishment as a good thing, because a killer can serve his life in prison for more than it cost to be shot in the damn head. We lead the nation in most citizens incarcerated per capita in the world...

Anon3 on December 14, 2016:

So... every piece of existing evidence shows that the death penalty does not serve as a deterrent. This is actually pretty common knowledge.

Executing someone is also more expensive than life in prison because of the burden of exhaustive investigation (someone cannot appeal their case after dying, after all).

So two of your five points are just objectively false.

good job on December 06, 2016:

the author is absolutely right death penalty is what we need criminals are getting it off easy.

Adolf Trump on November 25, 2016:

we shouldn't kill them we should make them build my wall!!!

OK on November 17, 2016:

Is there any evidence of a full life sentence in prison being more costly than an execution? in another article it said the complete opposite

xxx_billy_xxx on October 20, 2016:

we should quickscope all the skrubs who try to attack lvl 1 skrubs.we should get them to wear a fedora then quickscope them

bill on October 20, 2016:

i rekon

Really? on October 19, 2016:

Really? @billy You're misinformed, and immature.

Brendan on August 30, 2016:

I know this here can debunk any anti-death penalty arguments.

billy on March 17, 2016:

I think that this is a very silly article and the author should probably be banned from this website: you are a bad person for supporting the death penalty

Wicked Stepmother from My Living Room on January 30, 2015:

I do believe some people are beyond rehabilitation as well. This should ideally be determined on a case by case basis. I'd like to hear what you think about sex offenders, since that is a hot topic these days. Offenders committed to programs are claiming that it amounts to life in prison without the opportunity of parole and they want out. The government seems to be open to accommodating their demands. I think this is a very dangerous and detrimental position to take.

Fire8storm on November 18, 2014:

I found this a very interesting hub. The death penalty is indeed a very emotive issue and one of great debate. While I agree criminals do need to be punished for their behaviour and that punishment needs to be severe, I am not totally convinced the death penalty is the best option. I have grave concerns regarding wrongful conviction. Also how can we determine which individuals can be rehabilitated and which cannot? I certainly agree with many of your points which you wrote very well, but do feel this debate is much more complex.

Art from California on October 27, 2014:

Great Post. I would have to disagree that it deters criminals, if that was so we would see less Homicides happening, the reality is that people are going to do what they do regardless of punishment. I do not agree with the death penalty as I believe that God is the only true Judge and only one who can take a life away justfully. I myself would never feel comfortable putting someone to death. But just my opion. Great Job!

annon on October 19, 2014:

Good reasons, but death penalty (4 million) is actually more expensive than lifetime prison term(1 million)

samuel on October 09, 2014:

I think the death penalty is only good for justice E.G. murder or extreme violence

Sanxuary on September 24, 2014:

All reasons are good valid reasons. I find it amazing that we have so many horrendous people who will never life outside again and yet we keep them around. Just as awful are the number of killers who took a plea bargain and have cheated death. When there is no question of guilt, no chance of remorse and no opportunity that society would ever release them to kill again. Have we not already killed them, lets finish the job. A super heated furnace where you sweep it out when you our finished would be fine.

ryan moodie on March 28, 2014:

i think i like the death penalty

Cici on March 11, 2014:

the cost is less it take 4 million to kill someone

Bob on February 09, 2014:

I agree but four comes before five

MG Singh from UAE on December 18, 2013:

Very interesting post. I have always been in favor of death penalty